Adding to the great posts about striving towards a stink-free (or at least less stinky) life: Deodorants that didn’t work for me, and one that surprised me.
By now, almost all of my personal care, as well as household items, are cruelty-free, and most of them are organic and without any harsh chemicals. Many of them are also vegan (although I am not a vegetarian or vegan when it comes to food). Pretty much the last conventional item that was still lingering around was my deodorant. I’ve tried to replace the regular stuff with natural alternatives in the past, but without real success. It wasn’t even the aluminum that bothered me so much. Truth to be told, no matter what aluminum-type I’ve used, I never noticed that I was sweating more or less with one deodorant or another. I just assumed that somehow the aluminum kept me from sweating more than I do (and I like to think of myself as an average sweater, so to speak). I just wanted a cruelty-free deodorant, but apparently, there is no such thing as a cruelty-free deodorant that still contains aluminum, aside from Tom’s of Main Antiperspirant, which didn’t work for me, and I was not a big fan of the scents. Of course, I’ve heard stories about how bad aluminum is for your body, but compared to some of the other crap that we come in contact with every day, I really didn’t think it was that bad.
It really bothered me though that I could not find a single natural deodorant that kept the unpleasant smell at bay for more than an hour, and so I set out (again, for the third time), to find something that works.
1. Primal Pit Paste – Lavender (Stick): I LOVE the smell of lavender, so naturally (no pun intended), this was my first choice. The product spreads well and truly keeps you smelling lavenderish all day long. Even my shirts were not smelly in the evening, even though the deodorant does not keep you from sweating. That in itself would not have been an issue since I actually don’t mind sweating. The problem was that the product irritated the heck out my skin. I’ve never had a reaction to any deodorant in the past, but within two days my poor pits were dark red and itching/burning like crazy. I tried not shaving in the morning, but that didn’t help. It took about 2 weeks for my arms to return back to normal (I was really worried they would not).
2. Primal Pit Paste – Lavender (jar): I am stubborn. As I’ve said, I love lavender, so I tried the jar version. Unfortunately, it had the same effect and had the added small inconvenience of having to be rubbed on with your fingers. Had it worked, I would have gladly dealt with that though.
3. Primal Pit Paste – Unscented Regular/Light (jar): P3’s customer service is pretty awesome. They sent me a sample of the unscented regular and light jar version. Both do not contain any essential oils, and the light version also has a lower amount of baking soda in it. The regular version still burned a little; the light version less so to the point where it was almost bearable (hey, I might get used to it …), but unfortunately it did nothing to keep the smell away 😦
I really, really wanted to like P3, I’ve heard so many good things about the company, but clearly, my skin begs to differ.
4. Schmidt’s Rose & Vanilla deodorant: I came across this on a website (that I don’t remember) and bought it on Amazon. Pro: It smells really, really good, and it didn’t irritate my skin one bit (although it does contain baking soda as well)! Con: It comes in a jar with a little spatula, and you need to rub it between your fingers before applying it to your armpits. I don’t really mind, that, but unfortunately, it didn’t really mask the smell for more than a few hours. Sigh …
5. Tom’s of Maine – Deodorant Stick, Apricot: After spending quite a bit of money, I found myself at the grocery store around lunchtime, basically because I managed to not have any deodorant at work whatsoever, and I was going to take the afternoon off to watch a tennis tournament in DC. So I grabbed the one deodorant that I knew was at least cruelty-free: Tom’s, Apricot. “What the heck,” I thought, “it only has to get me through the day.” To my surprise, it got me through the day. With only a little bit of sweating (I was sitting in the sun for about two hours). Without smelling, even when I finally went home around midnight. I have since used it daily, and for now, I could not be happier.
What I can say for all natural deodorants: I am actually sweating a little less now than before, and the sweat does not smell as bad as quickly. TMI? Hey, this is a blog for people like me, who want full disclosure 🙂 I don’t think I will return to conventional deodorants. I am still not convinced that the aluminum is actually a danger to my health, but the fact that it actually seems to make me sweat more will keep me away for good.
I’d love to hear about your favorite deodorants that work for you?